Best Hotels in Sanibel & Captiva Islands, Florida

World-famous seashell-strewn Gulf beaches, subtropical wildlife mangrove estuaries, and barefoot island tranquility.

South Seas Island Resort

From $525/night • North Captiva Tip / Plantation Rd

Read 1,500-Word Review

'Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa

From $345/night • Captiva Drive Narrow / Gulf-to-Bay

Read 1,500-Word Review

Captiva Island Inn

From $225/night • Andy Rosse Lane / Captiva Village

Read 1,500-Word Review

Jensen's "On the Gulf" Beach Resort

From $395/night • Captiva Beachfront / Andy Rosse End

Read 1,500-Word Review

Casa Ybel Resort

From $495/night • Mid-Island West Gulf Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

From $365/night • East Middle Gulf Drive

Read 1,500-Word Review

Island Inn

From $325/night • West Gulf Drive Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Sanibel Island Beach Resort

From $215/night • Mid-Gulf Drive Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Song of the Sea

From $365/night • East Gulf Drive Seaside

Read 1,500-Word Review

Sanibel Inn

From $265/night • East Gulf Drive Corridor

Read 1,500-Word Review

Seaside Inn

From $245/night • East Gulf Drive / Lighthouse End

Read 1,500-Word Review

Sunset Beach Inn

From $235/night • West Gulf Drive Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Sanibel Moorings Resort

From $295/night • East Gulf Drive Botanical Grounds

Read 1,500-Word Review

West Wind Island Resort

From $225/night • Upper West Gulf Drive

Read 1,500-Word Review

Castaways Cottages at Blind Pass

From $185/night • Blind Pass / Sanibel-Captiva Border

Read 1,500-Word Review

Shalimar Resort

From $195/night • West Gulf Drive Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Jensen's Twin Palm Marina & Cottages

From $175/night • Captiva Village Bayfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Anchor Inn and Cottages

From $139/night • Periwinkle Way Mid-Island

Read 1,500-Word Review

Tarpon Tale Inn

From $149/night • East End / Periwinkle Way

Read 1,500-Word Review

Kona Kai Motel

From $119/night • Mid-Island / Palm Lake

Read 1,500-Word Review