Best Hotels in Montauk & The Hamptons, New York

Windswept Atlantic ocean dunes, historic whaling port harbors, and legendary South Fork seaside elegance.

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

From $695/night • Old Montauk Highway / Oceanfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Marram Montauk

From $525/night • Downtown Montauk Dunes

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Surf Lodge

From $495/night • Fort Pond Waterfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Montauk Yacht Club

From $445/night • Star Island / Lake Montauk

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Maidstone Hotel

From $595/night • East Hampton Historic District

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Baker House 1650

From $645/night • Main Street Historic Green

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Hedges Inn

From $475/night • James Lane / Town Pond

Read 1,500-Word Review

Mill House Inn

From $525/night • North Main Street / Windmill View

Read 1,500-Word Review

Topping Rose House

From $695/night • Main Street Bridgehampton

Read 1,500-Word Review

Baron's Cove

From $395/night • West Water Street / Harborfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

The American Hotel

From $425/night • Main Street Sag Harbor Core

Read 1,500-Word Review

A Room at the Beach

From $365/night • Scuttle Hole / Bridgehampton North

Read 1,500-Word Review

Hero Beach Club

From $325/night • Umbrella Beach Frontage

Read 1,500-Word Review

Daunt's Albatross Motel

From $245/night • Downtown Montauk Core

Read 1,500-Word Review

Solé East Resort

From $265/night • Second House Road

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Breakers Montauk

From $285/night • Old Montauk Highway / Ditch Plains

Read 1,500-Word Review

Southampton Inn

From $195/night • Southampton Village Core

Read 1,500-Word Review

Montauk Blue Hotel

From $185/night • Downtown Montauk Beachfront

Read 1,500-Word Review

Hartman's Briney Breezes Motel

From $165/night • Old Montauk Highway Bluff

Read 1,500-Word Review

The Driftwood Resort

From $215/night • Napeague Dunes Oceanfront

Read 1,500-Word Review