Back to Mystic & Stonington

House of 1833 Bed & Breakfast & Gardens

From $235/night • Score: 4.9★ (680 reviews)

Exterior 1Exterior 2Interior 1Interior 2Surroundings

Introduction: A Timeless Coastal Connecticut Sanctuary

In an era where modern hospitality is increasingly dominated by sleek glass towers, algorithmic minimalist design, and homogenous corporate branding, true sanctuaries of character are becoming rare finds. Enter the House of 1833 Bed & Breakfast & Gardens, a magnificent Greek Revival estate resting quietly on the picturesque countryside edge of Mystic and Stonington, Connecticut. Priced remarkably reasonably at around $235 a night, this property shatters the conventional compromise between affordability and luxury, offering an immersive step back in time paired with indulgent, unapologetically romantic comforts.

As a luxury travel journalist and hospitality critic, I have crossed thresholds of five-star resorts across the globe, yet few properties manage to evoke such an immediate sense of literary romance and historic gravitas. Positioned near the historic Strawberry Hill neighborhood, the estate operates as a secluded nature retreat while remaining just minutes away from the maritime charm of downtown Mystic, the coastal vineyards of Stonington, and Long Island Sound beaches. It is a destination that demands to be savored slowly, inviting guests to trade the relentless cadence of modern life for the gentle rustle of antique oaks and the crackle of wood-burning hearths.

First Impressions & Architecture: The Grandeur of 1833

Approaching the House of 1833 is akin to stepping onto the pages of a nineteenth-century novel. The property’s provenance is immediately striking: a stately, symmetrical Greek Revival mansion originally constructed in 1833 by the wealthy nineteenth-century banker and shipping merchant Erastus Denison. Listed proudly on the National Register of Historic Places, the mansion stands as an architectural triumph of its era, characterized by its imposing white facade, classic pedimented gable, towering Ionic-inspired columns, and multi-paned windows that have watched over the changing Connecticut seasons for nearly two centuries.

The sense of arrival is profoundly private. Tucked away from the main thoroughfares, the estate is approached via a winding country drive that opens up to reveal manicured lawns, towering heirloom trees, and a pervasive, restorative silence broken only by birdsong. Stepping across the threshold into the main foyer feels less like checking into a commercial accommodation and more like being welcomed as an esteemed guest into a grand private country estate.

Original architectural details have been meticulously preserved throughout the public rooms. High ceilings soar overhead, crowned by intricate plaster moldings and medallions. Gleaming wide-board pumpkin pine floors, worn smooth by generations of footsteps, whisper stories of the past underfoot. The parlor and common areas are thoughtfully appointed with museum-quality period antiques, rich Persian carpets, heavy velvet drapery, and warm, ambient lighting that accentuates the historic millwork. Unlike sterile boutique hotels that attempt to manufacture heritage through vintage-inspired decor, the House of 1833 radiates an authentic, lived-in elegance. There is a palpable soul to the mansion—a harmonious blend of historic preservation and unpretentious luxury that immediately lowers the heart rate and sets the tone for a deeply restorative getaway.

The Room Experience: Unapologetic Romance and Historic Indulgence

If the public rooms establish the estate's historical pedigree, the guest accommodations elevate the experience into an absolute masterclass in romantic hospitality. What truly sets the House of 1833 apart—and places it in a tier entirely of its own—is an uncompromising commitment to in-room indulgence: every single suite across the property features a working wood-burning or gas fireplace and a lavish double whirlpool tub.

During my stay, I evaluated one of the signature upper-floor suites, and the impression was nothing short of breathtaking. The sleeping quarters are anchored by magnificent antique canopy beds draped in crisp, high-thread-count linens, inviting deep, uninterrupted slumber. Period armoires, writing desks, and comfortable reading armchairs fill the space without feeling cluttered, maintaining a delicate balance between historical authenticity and modern comfort.

The architectural focal point of the room, however, is the hearth. Having a private, crackling wood-burning fireplace in a bedroom is an increasingly scarce luxury in the modern hotel landscape, often restricted to ultra-exclusive mountain lodges. Here, it is standard. The innkeepers provide neatly stacked firewood, transforming the evening routine into an intimate ritual of striking a match, watching the flames catch, and settling in with a glass of local wine.

Adjacent to the sleeping area, the ensuite bathrooms are designed as private wellness sanctuaries. Each features a generous double whirlpool tub positioned to maximize relaxation, flanked by plush bathrobes, oversized Turkish towels, and artisanal bath amenities. Sinking into the bubbling jets of a private whirlpool after a day of exploring coastal Connecticut, with the glow of the bedroom fireplace dancing across the historic walls, is an experience that effortlessly justifies the journey.

Modern conveniences are woven seamlessly into the historic fabric. Thoughtful touches include:

Signature Amenities & Atmosphere: Gardens, Pools, and Country Seclusion

While the interiors of the House of 1833 offer a cocoon of historic luxury, the exterior grounds invite guests to engage with the stunning natural beauty of the Connecticut countryside. Set on acres of secluded, nature-rich property, the estate functions as a private country club for its guests.

At the heart of the outdoor experience is the seasonal outdoor swimming pool. Framed by expansive stone decking and comfortable loungers, the pool area feels entirely removed from the outside world. It is surrounded by meticulously curated flower gardens that burst into vibrant color throughout the spring, summer, and early autumn. Manicured boxwoods, cascading perennials, and fragrant flowering vines create a sensory wonderland where butterflies drift lazily through the warm air. Whether spending an afternoon swimming laps under the New England sun or curling up with a novel under the shade of a colorful umbrella, the poolside atmosphere is one of profound tranquility.

For guests seeking a touch of active recreation, the property also features a private tennis court tucked discreetly away at the edge of the tree line. It is a rare amenity for a historic bed and breakfast of this scale, offering a wonderful way to begin the morning before the day warms up.

The overarching atmosphere of the House of 1833 is one of profound, hushed serenity. Unlike bustling urban boutique hotels or large-scale resorts teeming with convention crowds, this property cultivates an environment of absolute peace. The nature-secluded setting ensures that nights are quiet and dark, unpolluted by city glare, allowing for stargazing from the expansive lawns. It is a place designed for reconnection—whether celebrating an anniversary, embarking on a romantic weekend escape, or simply seeking a quiet solitude to recharge the creative spirit.

Food, Drink & Local Nightlife: Scratch Gourmet Mornings and Coastal Flavor

A great bed and breakfast ultimately stands or falls on the quality of its morning meal, and the House of 1833 treats breakfast not as a perfunctory morning routine, but as a culinary centerpiece of the daily experience. Served in the sunlit historic dining room—or on the patio when weather permits—the morning meal is a scratch-made gourmet affair curated by the host.

Drawing on local New England agricultural traditions and seasonal ingredients, the multi-course breakfast changes daily, ensuring repeat visitors always encounter a delightful culinary surprise. During my stay, the meal commenced with a bright, artfully plated seasonal fruit parfait featuring local berries, house-made granola, and artisanal Greek yogurt drizzled with regional wildflower honey. This was followed by the main course: a decadent, savory puff pastry tartlet filled with locally sourced farm-fresh eggs, artisanal goat cheese, wild mushrooms, and fresh herbs, accompanied by crisp heritage-breed bacon.

The attention to culinary detail is evident in every bite. Coffee is freshly ground, robust, and sourced from regional roasters, poured from heavy silver carafes alongside a selection of loose-leaf teas. Dietary restrictions and preferences are handled with effortless grace and genuine hospitality, ensuring every guest feels thoroughly pampered before they even step foot outside the estate.

When evening falls, guests venture out to explore the vibrant culinary and nightlife scene of the Mystic and Stonington regions, located just a short drive away. The local gastronomy punches well above its weight class:

Who This Stay Is For: The Ideal Traveler Profile

The House of 1833 is not a monolithic luxury hotel designed to appeal to every demographic; rather, it is a specialized, highly curated sanctuary tailored for a discerning type of traveler.

Couples seeking romance will find this property to be an absolute paradise. The combination of private wood-burning fireplaces, canopy beds, and double whirlpool tubs makes it arguably one of the premier honeymoon and anniversary destinations in the Northeast, particularly given the exceptional $235-per-night price point that delivers value far exceeding its cost. History enthusiasts and architecture buffs will likewise be enraptured by the authentic preservation of Erastus Denison’s 1833 Greek Revival masterpiece, appreciating the tactile connection to America’s nineteenth-century maritime banking era.

Furthermore, this stay is tailor-made for burned-out urbanites—whether from New York, Boston, or Providence—looking for a seamless, nature-secluded weekend escape where they can unplug, read by the pool, and enjoy absolute quiet without sacrificing upscale comforts. It is an environment that encourages slowing down, breathing deeply, and indulging in the lost art of relaxation.

Conversely, travelers seeking bustling nightlife on-site, ultra-modern minimalist concrete-and-glass aesthetics, or family-centric mega-resort waterparks should look elsewhere. The House of 1833 proudly celebrates its historic, intimate character, catering exclusively to those who value charm, privacy, and old-world elegance.

Practical Travel Notes: Navigating Your Stay

To ensure a flawless experience at the House of 1833, a few practical considerations are worth keeping in mind:

Ultimately, the House of 1833 Bed & Breakfast & Gardens stands as a triumph of boutique hospitality. It proves that true luxury does not require marble-clad skyscrapers or exorbitant nightly tariffs; rather, it lives in the warmth of a crackling hearth, the luxury of a historic canopy bed, the beauty of an untamed garden, and the genuine care of exceptional hosts. For anyone looking to experience the romantic soul of coastal Connecticut, this stately 1833 mansion is an unmissable destination.